Federal Delicatessen Auckland Review | Best Reuben Sandwich in Auckland CBD
Watch the VLOG : https://www.tiktok.com/@anavidtraveller/video/7586957851889995028
A New York Deli Moment in the Heart of Auckland
The moment I walked into Federal Delicatessen on Federal Street, directly opposite SkyCity, I genuinely forgot I was in Auckland. The noise. The energy. The accents. Tourists everywhere. American voices bouncing around the room. It felt exactly like the New York delis I only ever saw on TV food shows growing up.
This place has presence. It is loud in the best way. Busy without being chaotic. A proper deli atmosphere where you feel like food is taken seriously but never pretentiously.
The Reuben Experience
We shared one Reuben on rye. Twenty-six dollars fifty. And honestly, the second it landed on the table, the pastrami was already calling my name. This was a very private, happy moment.
I have eaten a lot of Reubens in my life. A lot. But this one is different. This is the benchmark.
The sauerkraut is balanced and not overpowering. The Russian dressing is rich but controlled. The pastrami is smoked beautifully and melts in your mouth. Nothing is fighting for attention. Everything works together precisely as it should.
Now I finally understand what people mean when they say that sitting in a New York deli, eating a Reuben, is an experience. This is it. Right here in Auckland.
The Vibe
Federal Delicatessen does not try to be quiet or refined. It leans into its identity fully. Loud conversations. Fast-moving staff. Tables are turning over constantly. It feels alive.
You do not come here for a slow romantic meal. You come here to eat appropriately and leave satisfied.
What to Expect
Big portions
Classic American Jewish deli comfort food
A busy atmosphere, especially during peak hours
Walk-in dining with high turnover
Strong focus on sandwiches and nostalgic dishes
Price vs Experience
At twenty-six fifty for the Reuben, some might hesitate. But once you take the first bite, it makes sense. This is not just a sandwich. It is technique, balance, and experience on a plate.
Would I eat this every day if I could? Absolutely.
Final Thoughts
Federal Delicatessen is not just hype. It earns its reputation. If you love pastrami, Reubens, or classic American deli food, this is essential eating in Auckland.
Now tell me honestly.
Is this the best Reuben in Auckland
Or do you know one that can beat it
Google Reviews:
The highlights for us were definitely the pastrami sandwich and the chicken sandwich — both delicious, generous, and packed with flavor. Everything felt fresh and well-prepared.
Overall, a really solid spot for tasty food and quick service. We’d happily come back.
The chicken sandwich with gravy….Absolutely delicious! The chicken was perfectly cooked and the chicken skin added extra flavour and a crispiness to the sandwich. The rich, flavorful gravy poured over it took the dish to another level. It’s comfort food at its finest, and I can’t recommend it enough.
We also had the lemon meringue pie and it was the type of pie that the more you ate it the better it got. Nice tart flavour!
The staff were very friendly and attentive. I recommend this place!
FAQ:
What type of food does Federal Delicatessen serve
Federal Delicatessen serves American Jewish deli style comfort food inspired by classic New York delis, including Reuben sandwiches, pastrami on rye, soups, and nostalgic favourites.
Is the Reuben sandwich at Federal Delicatessen good
The Reuben sandwich at Federal Delicatessen is widely considered one of the best in Auckland, known for its perfectly smoked pastrami, balanced sauerkraut, and rich Russian dressing.
How much does a Reuben sandwich cost at Federal Delicatessen
A Reuben sandwich at Federal Delicatessen costs approximately twenty six dollars fifty and is regarded as good value for the quality and portion size.
Is Federal Delicatessen suitable for tourists
Yes, Federal Delicatessen is very popular with tourists due to its central Auckland CBD location, lively atmosphere, and iconic New York deli style experience.
Does Federal Delicatessen accept walk ins
Yes, Federal Delicatessen primarily operates on a walk in basis and is known for its fast table turnover even during busy periods.
Is Federal Delicatessen family friendly
Yes, Federal Delicatessen is family friendly and welcomes children, making it a suitable dining option for families visiting Auckland CBD.
Is Federal Delicatessen usually busy
Federal Delicatessen is often busy, especially during peak lunch and dinner hours, so short wait times are common during these periods.
Is Federal Delicatessen Halal
No, they do serve pork.
