Best Steak and Cheese Pies in Auckland
When people search for the best steak and cheese pie in Auckland, they are usually overwhelmed with award lists, hype bakeries, and places they may never actually visit. This list is different. Every Bakery mentioned here is somewhere I have personally been to and eaten at.
A great steak-and-cheese pie is unforgiving but straightforward. The steak needs to be chunky and tender, the cheese should melt naturally into the filling, and the pastry must hold everything together without being greasy or dry. After years of eating pies across Auckland, these are the ones that genuinely stood out.
This is my personal ranking of the best steak-and-cheese pies in Auckland, based on real experience.
1. Ashby Pies, St Heliers
Ashby Pies takes the top spot as the best steak and cheese pie in Auckland for me. The balance is excellent. The steak comes in proper chunks, the cheese complements the meat instead of overpowering it, and the pastry is flaky without being oily. Every bite feels consistent and well-thought-out.
If you are searching for a classic Kiwi steak and cheese pie done properly, Ashby Pies is the one I recommend first.
Watch the VLOG: https://www.tiktok.com/@anavidtraveller/video/7561320796572945685
2. Baked Devonport
Baked Devonport delivers one of the most refined steak and cheese pies in Auckland. The beef tastes slow-cooked and full of flavour, and the pastry shows real baking skill. It manages to feel premium while still keeping that familiar bakery comfort.
This is an excellent option if you are visiting Devonport and want a steak and cheese pie that feels carefully made rather than rushed.
Watch the VLOG: https://www.tiktok.com/@anavidtraveller/video/7548699047184338194
3. Pioneer Pies Albany
Pioneer Pies focuses on doing the basics well. The steak-and-cheese pie here is hearty, filling, and satisfying. The portions are generous, the cheese melts nicely through the filling, and the pie delivers precisely what you expect when craving comfort food.
It earns its place among the best steak-and-cheese pies in Auckland by keeping things simple and reliable.
Watch the VLOG: https://www.tiktok.com/@anavidtraveller/video/7547621008824421640
4. Mairangi Bay Bakery
Mairangi Bay Bakery is a classic neighbourhood bakery that many locals swear by. Their steak and cheese pie is familiar in the best way. The filling is generous, the flavour is consistent, and the pastry holds together well.
This is the kind of Bakery that reminds you why local pie shops are still so important in Auckland.
Watch the VLOG: https://www.tiktok.com/@anavidtraveller/video/7561959773801860373
5. Levain Bakery, Blockhouse Bay
Levain Bakery is known for quality baking, and that care carries through to their steak and cheese pie. The pastry is a standout, while the filling is well-seasoned and balanced.
It may not be the loudest pie on this list, but it is a solid choice for anyone searching for a well-made steak and cheese pie in Auckland.
Watch the VLOG: https://www.tiktok.com/@anavidtraveller/video/7552776342148893973
6. Beabea’s Bakery, Westmere
Beabea’s Bakery is slightly under the radar but deserves recognition. Their steak and cheese pie is comforting, dependable, and consistently good. Nothing feels rushed, and the flavours are familiar and satisfying.
It is the kind of place you return to because you know exactly what you are getting.
Watch the VLOG: https://www.tiktok.com/@anavidtraveller/video/7551201442778909969
7. Pie Rolla’s Newmarket
Pie Rolla’s brings a more modern approach to pies. While it may not be the most traditional steak-and-cheese pie in Auckland, it still delivers good flavour and solid execution. It is a good option if you enjoy a slightly contemporary take while still respecting the classic.
Watch the VLOG: https://www.tiktok.com/@anavidtraveller/video/7552378061098929428
8. Avi’s Pies, Grey Lynn
Avi’s Pies rounds out the list as a dependable choice. It may not be the first place I seek out specifically for a steak and cheese pie, but when you are nearby, it is a satisfying option that does the job well.
Watch the VLOG: https://www.tiktok.com/@anavidtraveller/video/7563959332803480853
Final Thoughts on the Best Steak and Cheese Pie in Auckland
This ranking is not based on awards or online hype. It is based on real visits, real meals, and honest opinions. Auckland has no shortage of bakeries, but these are the places that stood out to me when it comes to steak and cheese pies.
If you are searching for the best steak and cheese pie in Auckland from someone who has actually eaten them, this list is a great place to start. Right now, Ashby Pies sits firmly at number one.