Some places do not need hype. They survive because they have history, loyal customers, and a menu that has stayed true to itself for decades. Mexican Cafe is one of those places.

Established in 1983, this is one of Auckland’s oldest Mexican restaurants and a spot many locals grew up eating at. No trends. No reinvention. Just classic comfort food that has stayed largely the same for over forty years.

I also filmed a full vlog of this visit, which is now up on my TikTok for those who want to see the food and atmosphere in real time.

Auckland’s Old School Mexican Institution

Walking into the Mexican Cafe feels like stepping back in time. The room is always buzzing, the menu looks familiar, and the crowd is a mix of long-time regulars, families, and curious first-timers. This is not modern Mexican, and it does not pretend to be.

That is precisely why it works.

There is something comforting about a place that knows who it is and sticks to it, even when food trends come and go.

A Restaurant Built on History, Not Hype

Mexican Cafe has been serving Aucklanders since 1983, long before Mexican food became mainstream here. Many people you speak to will tell you stories of coming here as kids, as students, or on special occasions.

This is a nostalgia-driven restaurant, and that nostalgia is part of the experience.

What We Ordered at Mexican Cafe

We kept it simple and very classic.

One cheese dip
One shredded beef nachos
Two cans of Coke Zero

The total came to fifty-six dollars.

No cocktails, no extras, no sides. Just the staples that this place is known for.

Cheese Dip, Comfort Food at Its Best

The cheese dip was exactly what you expect from Mexican Cafe.

Warm, creamy, salty, and very moreish. The kind of dip you keep scooping without even thinking about it. Paired with crunchy corn chips, it does its job perfectly.

This is not a reinvented queso or a fancy cheese blend. It is old school, familiar, and comforting.

Shredded Beef Nachos, Hearty and Generous

The shredded beef nachos came out as a generous plate, perfect for sharing.

The beef was soft, well-seasoned, and spread properly across the nachos, so every bite had something going on. Loads of cheese, a good balance of toppings, and very filling.

This is not light food. This is sit back, take your time, and enjoy kind of food.

Drinks, Simple and Familiar

We went with two cans of Coke Zero.

Nothing special, but sometimes that is precisely what you want with this kind of meal. It fits the old school vibe perfectly.

Prices, Value, and the Experience

Is it cheap? Not really.

Fifty-six dollars for shared plates and soft drinks will raise some eyebrows. But you are not just paying for the food. You are paying for the experience, the history, and the fact that this place has been part of Auckland’s food scene for over forty years.

For many people, that matters.

Is Mexican Cafe Worth Visiting Today?

If you are looking for modern Mexican flavours, creative plating, or trendy twists, this might not be the place for you.

But if you want consistency, nostalgia, and comfort food that tastes exactly the way people remember it, Mexican Cafe delivers.

It knows its lane and stays in it confidently.

Mexican Cafe, Memories or Modern Mexican Flavours?

Mexican Cafe is not trying to impress you. It is not chasing trends. It is here to give you familiar flavours, generous portions, and a sense of history.

So tell me honestly.

Are you going to Mexican Cafe for the memories…
Or for modern Mexican flavours?

Google Reviews:

FAQ: